Hey Kokomo! Every year, fall-inspired drinks make their triumphant return earlier and earlier. But we’re not mad about it! Avoid the long line at Starbucks and support local businesses for pumpkin spice and everything nice this season. Check out some of our top recommendations right here in Kokomo!

Updated September 2024

Iced Caramel Apple Cider from MO Joe Coffee House

MO Joe Coffee House is located in beautiful downtown Kokomo and is the perfect spot to stop before a crisp walk downtown. Pictured is the Caramel Apple Cider Slushee — just one of the many pumpkin and apple offerings to MO Joe’s fall menu.

Located at 106 N. Main St., Kokomo

Caramel Apple Matcha from The Radish

This cozy fall drink blends the vibrant flavors of smooth matcha with sweet caramel and a hint of crisp apple, creating the perfect balance of earthy and sweet. It’s a must-try for matcha lovers looking to indulge in the taste of autumn!

Located at 115 W. Sycamore St., Kokomo

Butter Pecan Caramel Latte from Doubting Thomas Cafe

The Butter Pecan Caramel Latte at Doubting Thomas Cafe is a rich, indulgent treat perfect for fall. This handcrafted drink combines the warmth of buttery pecan flavors with the smooth sweetness of caramel, all blended into a creamy latte. Topped with a drizzle of caramel and a hint of nutty pecan, it’s a cozy cup that’s sure to delight coffee lovers looking for something a little special this season.

Located at 840 Daniel Drive, Kokomo

Pumpkin Spice Frappe from Black Wax Cafe

Black Wax Cafe is not just a record store! They have a HUGE variety of seasonally rotating drinks and in my opinion, the fall line-up is the best. The Pumpkin Spice Frappe is a sweet and spiced drink that is sure to get you cozy and ready for a trip to the pumpkin patch.

Located at 910 N. Washington St., Kokomo

Fall Duo from Whyte Horse Winery & Bistro

Who says you have to choose between your favorite fall drinks? This limited-time fall duo from Whyte Horse Winery & Bistro is the best of both worlds. On one side, there’s Iced Pumpkin Cider, and on the other is a Salted Brown Butter Toffee Cold Brew! Stop into Whyte Horse for a variety of menu items to put you in to the fall mood.

Located at 223 N. Main St., Kokomo

Big Ben Coffee

Recently Bree and I went to Big Ben for some fall drinks and we were not disappointed! I got an Iced Pumpkin Dirty Chai (dirty = a shot of espresso), and Bree got a Frozen Pumpkin Chai. With the heap of caramel and whipped cream on top of the sweet and spicy chai, we savored it until the last drop!

Located at 1230 W. Jefferson St., Kokomo

No matter what you look for in a fall drink, we hope this list has inspired you to try something new! What are your favorite fall drinks, Kokomo? Let us know in the comments!

Best Fall Drinks from Locally-Owned Coffee Shops